Top 13 Picks for Delicious Bagels in Brooklyn - A Comprehensive Guide to the Best Bagel Shops


Bagel Shops in Brooklyn NY
Top 13 Picks for Delicious Bagels in Brooklyn - A Comprehensive Guide to the Best Bagel Shops

If you are in Brooklyn and are searching for the best bagels Brooklyn has to offer, then we have the article for you. Bagels are regarded as a specialty by the members of the New York City Advisor squad, who also stand by them.

As a result of all of this, it is safe to say that they have performed all of the necessary research and have written this article in order to spotlight the best bagels in Brooklyn as well as some best pizza in Brooklyn new york, which you will not want to skip. These are the establishments that, in our opinion, cannot be missed, regardless of whether you are a tourist in New York City or a long-time resident.

Here Are the Best Bagels in Brooklyn NY

The act of grabbing a bagel is supposed to be a speedy one. Because the lines are already so lengthy, you should avoid being the person who causes everyone else to have to wait. In most bagel stores, schmear and bagels are displayed for customers to peruse, so if you need help with what you want, put away your phone and go over your order in your head before it's your time.

There is a good chance you will have to wait in line if you want to find the best bagels in Brooklyn. There is no way to ensure that you won't have to wait absolutely, but if you can, try to escape the midday crowd. This will give you the best chance of not having to. It is best to visit after 2 p.m. or first thing in the morning. Visiting on weekdays instead of weekends always benefits too. Now, all right, enough with this meaningless chitchat already. Let's tuck into some of the tastiest pastries Brooklyn offers!

1. Olde Brooklyn Bagel Shoppe

Olde Brooklyn Bagel Shoppe

Olde Brooklyn Bagel Shoppe is a good option for you to consider if you are looking for some of the most fluffy bagels in all of Brooklyn.

These freshly baked bagels from Brooklyn are airy and buttery and come in substantial quantities. You can anticipate receiving a doughy bagel bursting with crunchy air pockets and a scrumptious schemer spread.

After sampling the scallion, jalapeno, and horseradish dill cream cheeses, we must state that the schemer is the cream cheese that steals the show. You won't have any trouble recognizing the primary components in the flavor.

On the weekends and during the peak of the lunch rush, prepare to wait in a lengthy queue to get your hands on some of the best bagels in all of Brooklyn. However, there is one advantage to staying in a long line at the best coffee shops to work in Brooklyn: it increases the likelihood that you will be served a bagel that is freshly baked.

2. Greenberg’s Bagels

Greenberg�s Bagels

Julian Cavin, one of the co-founders of Greenberg's Bagels, saw a need for a bagel store in Bed-Stuy and took affairs into his own hands, opening Greenberg's Bagels in February 2020.

Greenberg's Bagels weathered the epidemic and established a reputation even though the launch scheduling could have been better (thanks a lot, COVID). Today, the dependable local store is known for providing customers with some of the best bagels in brooklyn.

With an abundance of choices for spreads, meats, and garnishes, the possible combinations for these Brooklyn bagels disgrace a traditional breakfast sandwich. The possibilities for permutations are virtually limitless.

3. Baker’s Dozen Bagels

Baker�s Dozen Bagels

Our favorite part about this fantastic bagel store in Brooklyn is that you can witness the bagels being prepared in real time while you place your order. Believe us when we say you won't find anything fresher elsewhere!

Baker's Dozen Bagels, a New York institution beloved by the community, attracts a queue on most Saturday mornings full of New Yorkers in search of fluffy bagels with various delicious spreads.

Because these are some of the best bagels in Brooklyn, you should get there early to escape the lengthy lineups. These bagels are famous for a reason, as they are a substantial and kettle-cooked variety.

4. Smith St. Bagels

Smith St. Bagels

For the past 13 years, New Yorkers have been able to get their hands on some of the freshest and most flavorful bagels that Brooklyn has to offer at Smith St. Bagels.

The bagel store in Brooklyn has many characters; it's also very light and open. We are aware that the general sentiment among New York City bagel stores, particularly those that are very crowded, is that the service suffers as a result; however, this is different from the situation here. (From our experience).

We have always had a good experience, and even when a lot of people are waiting in line, the employees are always prompt and helpful.

A large selection of cream cheeses is available at Smith St. Bagels, including several vegan choices. The bagels are consistently satisfying and built to last. The Pumpernickel Everything Bagel with Olive Pimento Cream Cheese is one of our top recommendations because it is so delicious.

5. Shelsky’s of Brooklyn

Shelsky�s of Brooklyn

When we went to Shelsky's for the first time, we came in to try their shredded cheese. (For the benefit of unaware people, shredded cheddar is a common ingredient in New York City. In its most basic form, it is a jumble consisting of minced meat, scallions, and cheddar that has been combined together and is served on a hero roll with various garnishes.

We added a bagel and lox to our order without giving it much consideration because we were under the impression that you can always go right with a standard.

To our utter astonishment, the bagel outperformed the shredded cheese by a wide margin. And that's not to say that the shredded cheese wasn't delectable (spoiler alert: it was), but these Brooklyn Bagels and the fantastic smoked fish were a delightful surprise for us.

When we found out that Shelsky's offers some of the best bagels in Brooklyn, we thought we had hit the jackpot, but it turns out that we were just late to the party, and everyone else already knew.

Due to the size of the servings in this Family Restaurants in New York, we recommend sharing a croissant with a friend or family member. You won't be sorry if you indulge in one of the preserved seafood dishes, which we highly recommend.

6. Court St. Bagels

Court St. Bagels

Bagels from Court St. Bagels are consistently among our top picks for best in the borough of Brooklyn. The employees always use fresh bagels and spread a generous quantity of schmear. Is there any other way to say it? On each bagel before serving it.

Because it is widely considered one of the best bagel stores in Brooklyn, the staff is likely to be familiar with the neighborhood's residents and to address them by name regularly.

In addition, the bagels have the ideal amount of airiness, and the interior is flawlessly crunchy. This Brooklyn bagel store has a distinct sense of individuality thanks to the handwriting labeling that is used to identify all of the bagels.

Due to the fact that Court St. Bagels is on the smaller side and has limited seating, customers must take their food and leave the establishment.

7. Knickerbocker Bagel

Knickerbocker Bagel

Because the bagels at Knickerbocker's have many flavors and the schmear assortment is not to be taken lightly, we have included it on this list of the best bagels in brooklyn.

The atmosphere in this bagel store in Brooklyn is consistently high-quality, and the service is both quick and personable. A family runs the business, and the store itself is pretty large, which creates a warm and welcoming environment ideal for enjoying some of the best bagels in brooklyn.

We suggest going for a tried-and-true option, such as the Luxurious Bagel. (smoked salmon, cream cheese, tomato, onion & capers). We have discovered that Knickerbocker's is one of the few bagel stores in Brooklyn that provides a substantial number of garnishes, such as preserved salmon, on their bagels.

8. La Bagel Delight

La Bagel Delight

Since its founding in 1986, La Bagel Delight has been known for producing some of the most delicious bagels in all of Brooklyn. You can choose between four different addresses in Brooklyn, each of which is independently owned and controlled.

Because it is only a ten-minute stroll away from Prospect Park, we frequently visit the location on Seventh Avenue. After purchasing an everything bagel topped with scallion cream cheese, we make our way to a nearby park to savor one of the city's best bagels.

You should anticipate lineups, but the good news is that the service here is typically outstanding, and the lines progress relatively swiftly. When you make some of the best bagels in Brooklyn, things like this are to be anticipated; however, we assure you that the delay will be well worth it.

9. Frankel’s Delicatessen

Frankel�s Delicatessen

What more can we possibly say about Frankel's Deli after everything that has already been said? The locals have been saying for years that they are some of the best bagels in all of Brooklyn, and we can’t know that we disagree with them.

In addition to providing all of the traditional accompaniments found in Jewish delicatessens, Frankel's is distinguished from their rivals by their velvety lox.

Frankel's is known throughout the borough of Brooklyn for producing some of the city's most delicious bagels. In point of fact, if it meant we could get our hands on this bad boy, we wouldn't think twice about commuting an hour to do so!

10. Sunset Bagels

Sunset Bagels

This bagel shop in Brooklyn is not for those who are easily intimidated. A wide variety of food is available at Sunset Bagels, ranging from traditional breakfast sandwiches to spaghetti recipes. This Best Restaurants in New York has it all.

And in pure New York style, this bagel store in Brooklyn is open to the garnishes when it comes to their bagels. You can anticipate that the bagels will be stuffed with the desired mixture, regardless of what it is.

The most exciting part? The dough for each bagel is kneaded, shaped, and cooked by hand before being placed in an oven preheated to 500 degrees. There is nothing more delicious than a croissant that has just been baked. Don't believe us. Take a peek at Sunset Bagels’ social media.

Their stream is filled with videos of freshly baked bagels that have just been removed from the oven and are being ripped in half as vapor emerges from the bread.

Consider yourself extremely fortunate if you are searching for the best bagels in Brooklyn and are within strolling distance of any of the four locations that are spread out across the borough of Brooklyn.

11. Bagel Hole

Bagel Hole

There is a debate that will never end about whether bagels should be either sweet or savory, and it doesn’t even get us started on the New York standards, a BEC (bacon, egg, and cheese) or an SEC (salted egg and smoked salmon). (Sausage, egg & cheese).

But who worries when there is a location like Bagel Hole that excels in every single category? This bagel store in Brooklyn, located in the borough of Brooklyn, is near the top of our ranking of the best bagels in Brooklyn.

Everything is prepared from scratch on the premises using only natural ingredients, and each bagel is formed by hand. This establishment is one of the few in New York City that open nonstop throughout the year. You can probably picture the lineups that include during the holiday season, but that's the price you pay for offering some of the best pastries in Brooklyn.

12. Bagel Pub

Bagel Pub

The Bagel Pub is the consummate example of a genuine New York City bagel store.

You will be satisfied because they have a wide selection of freshly cooked bagels and plenty of choices for cream cheese. The interior is light and fluffy, while the exterior is chewy and gratifying; combined with the substantial spread, this results in some of the best bagels in all of Brooklyn.

Need to make up your mind about which combination is best? Ask the welcoming staff for recommendations; they always seem pleased to assist however they can.

If you request a bagel from this place, you can rest assured that it will be made from fresh ingredients because the bagels are prepared right here.

13. Sam’s Bagels

Sam�s Bagels

Whenever we crave a substantial breakfast, we often visit Sam's Bagels because it is one of our favorite places to eat in the area.

When crafting the ideal breakfast sandwich, this bagel store in Brooklyn will not disappoint you in any way. You can find us in the alcove enjoying a BEC bagel and an SEC bagel while New Yorkers argue over which type of breakfast bagel is better: BEC or SEC.

We are not exaggerating when we say that the bagels are so delicious that we have to restrain ourselves from purchasing twelve of them just for ourselves.

Every time we come in, the staff is so warm and welcoming, and the atmosphere reminds us of being a part of a large family. In addition to producing some of the city of Brooklyn's most delicious bagels for Food and drinks in New York, Sam's Bagels has also managed to cultivate a small but dedicated customer base.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why are New York bagels so famous?

Some aspects of New York Citys municipal water are credited with making the best bagels, much like how a particular vineyards soil is used to create wine. The silt level is elevated, and calcium and magnesium amounts are minimal.

How are Brooklyn-style bagels different from other kinds?

In order to achieve the distinctive flavor, chewy interior, and crispy exterior of a bagel shops in Brooklyn NY the dough is always cooked in water to which barley malt has been added.

In New York City, where do you find the best bagel?

If you were wondering, the most iconic and classic New York City bagel order is an everything bagel with lox and cream cheese. When folks speak about bagels from New York, they usually mean something like this.

With their bagels, what do New Yorkers typically snack on?

The bagel is a quintessential New York staple. It is a flavorful, round loaf of bread with a hollow in the center thats both crispy and spongy on the outside and the inside. Seasonings are sprinkled on top, and the typical filling consists of cream cheese and cured salmon.

How do you define a New York bagel?

The doughs cooking is responsible for the deeper brown color and the fantastic crunchy texture of the bagels surface. Before heating the bread, some bagel shops in Brooklyn NY add additives like alkali or barley grain to the water.
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
You've successfully subscribed to NYC
Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.
Great! You've successfully signed up.
Success! Your email is updated.
Your link has expired
Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.
Please enter at least 3 characters 0 Results for your search