Staten Island has the least population in the five boroughs of NYC. But you can get everything for entertainment, attractions, and various fun things to do on Staten Island. You will find various fun activities, public parks, shopping spots, and a great culinary scene for Sri Lankan, Spanish, and Italian cuisines.
It’s a famous Italian American hub where you can get delicious Italian cheesy pasta, lasagna, pizzas, and the best things to do in New York for first-timers. Taste the Italian flavors and explore the best Italian restaurants in Staten Island. Take a water ferry to Staten Island for a free ride and enjoy the journey with iconic views of the NYC skyline, the Statue of Lady Liberty, Ellis Island, and Governor Island. Explore the island and enjoy the flavorsome Italian meals and vibrant American Italian culture in NYC.
Twenty-one Spacious Dining Spots and the Best Italian Restaurants in Staten Island
Let’s enjoy the tasty meals and sizzling flavors of Italian cuisine. We share twenty-one great dining spots for the best Italian food on Staten Island in NYC. You can get a free ferry ride to Staten Island from Manhattan and it’s available 24/7 on all weekdays. Click here to learn more about how to get to the Staten Island Ferry.
Top 21 Best Italian Restaurants in Staten Island
1. Enoteca Maria Italian Restaurant in Staten Island, NYC
Staten Island has a fantastic food scene and Enoteca Maria restaurant is a gorgeous dining spot to taste cheesy pasta and lasagna. It’s at a distance of a few minutes’ walk from the Saint George Terminal station, and you can find various fun things to do in this area. The restaurant has a diverse menu and every day the menu changes. They usually served cheesy lasagna, zucchini, creamy cheesy basil pesto, burrata, roasted beet salad, beef pot pie, chicken pot pie, freshly roasted duck, and gelato.
2. Seppe Pizza Bar Italian Restaurant in Staten Island, NYC
Pizza is my most favorite food in New York. Whether it is wood-fired pizza, New York-style pizza, or Neapolitan Pizza, New Yorkers love all pizza slices with cheesy toppings and delicious sauces. Seppe Pizza Bar serves one of the best pizzas in New York on Staten Island. The pizzeria has a modern, chic setting at the Navy Pier with refreshing air and a cozy atmosphere. They serve burrata, Seppe wings, sliders, Brussel sprouts, calzones, shrimp pasta, hot sausage pasta, chicken parm, meatballs, pizzas with mushrooms, onions, cheese, hot cherry peppers, pepperoni, jalapeno, sausages, meatballs, and sauces.
3. Vinum Italian Restaurant in Staten Island, NYC
Vinum Italian Restaurant is located on Bay Street in Stapleton Heights. It’s a fun spot with stunning interiors that portray the scene of an Italian tavern in Staten Island. They serve crostini truffle ricotta, a pot of mussels, Italian meatballs, farmers antipasto, chocolate ganache cake, vegan chocolate cake, pistachio mousse, Tuscan tart, sausage frittata, spaghetti, Alaskan Salmon, and drinks.
4. Giuliana’s Italian Restaurant in Staten Island, NYC
Staten Island has various dining spots, but this Italian restaurant serves spicy, chilly, hot, and sweet flavors of Italian entries, cheesy pizza slices, creamy pasta, lasagna, and sweet treats. It has a patio dining spot with fascinating tables under the umbrellas and greenery around. They serve hot antipasto, sausages, Sicilian salad, Margarita pizza, sausage pizza, garlic pizza, lobster, chopped shrimp, grilled veal, grilled seasoned salmon, rigatoni Bolognese macaroni, cakes, coffee, and drinks.
5. Angelina’s Ristorante in Staten Island, NYC
Angelina’s Ristorante is a classic Italian restaurant and the most popular dining spot for its delicious flavorsome dishes. It’s located in an old Victorian house and decorated with high-end furniture, great woodwork, sculpted windows, and a fascinating lounge. Enjoying an Italian dinner in a fascinating ambiance is one of the best things to do in New York. Their famous dishes are Tuscan Gnocchi, Rigatoni Pasta, Fettuccine Granchio served with Alaskan King Crab sauce, Pan Roasted Scottish Salmon with Lemon Cream, Italian Cheesecake, Banana Bread Pudding, and Drinks.
6. Café Luna in Staten Island, NYC
Café Luna is located at Hylan Blvd on Staten Island. They serve Italian entrees, pizzas, pasta, soups, bread, seafood, and more. This small café has everything from cheesy pasta, lasagna, crunchy snacks, seasonal dishes, salmon, chicken, grilled meat, saucy gravies, and desserts with coffee and drinks. They serve the best coffee in Staten Island.
7. Nino’s Italian Restaurant in Staten Island, NYC
Nino’s Italian Restaurant is the best place for private parties and romantic dinners. They have sophisticated decors, elegant interiors in the dining lounge, and comfortable seating in the patio space. They serve fried calamari with dipping sauce, rigatoni pasta, pasta with veal meatballs and ricotta, gnocchi, chicken parmigiana, stuffed chicken with mushrooms and ricotta cheese, salmon with Dijon mustard sauce, salads, soups, sauté broccoli, roasted potatoes, and drinks.
8. Trattoria Toscana Italian Restaurant in Staten Island, NYC
Trattoria Toscana is an Italian Restaurant located at Hylan Blvd on Staten Island. They offer exquisite dining experiences for indoor lounges and outdoor spaces. They serve fried calamari, baked clams, seafood salad, chicken pasta, rigatoni pasta, fettuccine with meat sauce, shrimp with red sauce, zucchini, stuffed chicken, sausages, grilled salmon, veal chops, lamb chops, pizzas, lasagna, desserts, coffee, and drinks.
9. Osteria Bocelli Italian Restaurant in Staten Island, NYC
Osteria Bocelli is an upscale Italian dining spot and one of the best restaurants on Staten Island. It’s famous for its calamari, shrimp, and grilled beef filets. They serve the best Italian sizzling flavors, and the famous menu is grilled steaks, grilled lamb, mixed house salad, fried zucchini, onion soup, pasta and beans soup, spaghetti, ricotta gnocchi, veal scallopini with lemon, lemon chicken, lemon prawns, grilled salmon, chicken meatballs, tuna tartare, and drinks.
10. De Lucas Italian Restaurant in Staten Island, NYC
De Lucas Italian Restaurant has an indoor dining lounge and outdoor dining area for guests. It’s a great family restaurant and ideal things for kids and family gatherings, occasions, and events. Their delicious menu has meatballs, crab cake, calamari, pasta, lobster, spaghetti, rigatoni Bolognese, gnocchi, veal chop, lamb chops, strip steaks, and drinks.
11. Max’s Esca Italian Restaurant in Staten Island, NYC
Max’s Esca Italian restaurant is the finest dining spot in Staten Island. They have casual dining space and a patio setting. They offer various events for fun and entertainment at the venue like DJ and dance, rock music live performances, live piano performances, and more. Their delicious menu is grilled chicken, Esca burgers, truffle chicken, marina burgers, veal cutlet sandwiches, baby arugula, grilled steak, Italian Tuna sandwiches, chicken cutlet sandwiches, grilled shrimp, soups, salads, desserts, and drinks.
12. Sogno Ristorante Italiano in Staten Island, NY
Sogno Ristorante Italiano is an Italian dining spot. Guests can enjoy exquisite Italian dining in a sophisticated atmosphere. It’s the perfect place for friends and family gatherings and private parties, celebrations, and occasions. They serve gnocchi pasta stuffed with ricotta cheese, Fettuccine pasta in meat sauce, Grilled salmon in scampi sauce, Lambchop stuffed, Grilled Chicken Wrap, Seafood Wrap, oysters topped with onions and peppers, Salmon and crab meat tartars, Arugula with strawberries, pineapples, mango and avocado, and drinks.
13. Piccolinos Ristorante in Staten Island, NYC
Piccolinos Ristorante is an upscale Italian eatery that offers a sophisticated indoor dining experience as well as a patio dining area. This small restaurant offers delicious meals, desserts, and drinks for lunch and dinner. Their famous menu has garlic shrimp, stuffed mushrooms, antipasto, calamari, fettuccini alfredo pasta, spaghetti, rigatoni pasta, salmon with lemon, coconut shrimp, salads, soups, grilled chicken, lamb, and veal, and drinks.
14. Italianissimo Ristorante in Staten Island, NY
Italianissimo is an Italian restaurant that has elegant interiors in a classy dining lounge and a fantastic patio dining space with lush green plants around and refreshing vibes. They serve grilled chicken, steak and portobello, shrimp, arugula salad, gnocchi, spaghetti, cheese ravioli with chicken cutlet, seafood salad, antipasto, meatballs with ricotta cheese, zucchini, Tuscan bean soup, rigatoni pasta, grilled salmon, fish, and shrimp, stuffed shrimp with crab meat, and drinks.
15. Brioso Ristorante in Staten Island, NYC
Brioso is another Italian eatery that offers a fine dining experience with elegant interiors, soft ambiance, bright lighting, sophisticated furniture, and brick walls around. They also have an outdoor dining area with green pot plants, clean tables, and chairs under the umbrella with plenty of fresh air and natural light. They serve rice balls stuffed with beef, meatballs in tomato sauce, fried calamari, sauteed shrimp with tomato and garlic, bean soup with pasta, tuna with arugula and beans, brick oven cheesy pizza with various yummy toppings and sauces, grilled chicken, grilled sausage, grilled salmon, spaghetti, dumplings, and drinks.
16. Cucina Fresca Italian Restaurant in Staten Island, NYC
It’s a small and casual eatery but serves the best Italian dishes in a simple and minimalist dining area. They also have outdoor space for guests. They are famous for seafood meals and their famous menu is sausage with pepper onions, chicken salad, grilled chicken, grilled shrimp, calzones, pizzas, meatballs, calamari, zucchini, crab cakes, stuffed mushrooms, arugula salad, beans soup, chopped shrimp salad, chicken marsala with pasta, shrimp with pasta, Fettuccini Alfredo, buffalo chicken wrap, and turkey wraps.
17. Bella Vita Italian Restaurant in Staten Island, NYC
Bella Vita Italian restaurant is a luxury dining experience for creamy cheesy Italian dishes. Their outclass interiors, elegant decors, comfy furnishing, vibrant lights, soft ambiance, and delicious meals will give you an authentic Italian taste in the heart of Staten Island. It’s one of the fantastic things to do on Staten Island to explore the remarkable culinary scene. Their tasty dishes are Ravioli Marinara pasta, Lasagna, Spaghetti, Chicken Marsala, Grilled Chicken, Shrimp Marinara, steak and chops, shrimp with Dijon mustard, Chocolate Mousse Cake, Cheesecake, Rice Pudding, Mexican Coffee, Irish Coffee, Espresso, and tea.
18. Patrizia’s Italian Restaurant in Staten Island, NYC
Patrizia’s Italian Restaurant is a lavish dining spot that offers classy and luxurious decors, bright lights, comfy seating, wide space, and soft vibes. They serve Burrata with tomato onion salad, Gnocchi Pasta, Crab Cakes, Short Ribs, Roast Beef, brick oven pizzas with various toppings, Sausage and Peppers, Grilled Chicken, Chicken Parmesan, Lamb Chops, Skirt Steak, Spaghetti with Meatballs, Shrimp, Chicken Fingers, desserts, and coffee.
19. Lorenzo’s Italian Restaurant in Staten Island, NYC
Lorenzo’s Restaurant offers the finest dining experience with luxurious and classic interiors, high-end furnishing, sparkling chandeliers, comfy seating, soft and cozy ambiance, and tasty Italian dishes and drinks. Their menu has crab cakes, zucchini, buffalo wings, cheese steak, Margherita and sausage pizzas, chopped shrimp pasta, fettuccine pasta, spaghetti, kale salad, grilled tuna, garlic shrimp, beef short rib, veal cutlet, chicken with lemon sauce, and drinks.
20. La Strada Italian Restaurant in Staten Island, NYC
La Strada is a casual dining spot that serves the best Italian dishes, and desserts, and offers comfy seating with cozy vibes. Their menu has fried calamari, stuffed mushrooms, garlic bread, bean soup, mozzarella salad, seafood salad, gnocchi, rigatoni, fettuccini, stuffed chicken, chicken strips, chicken marsala, veal sandwich, shrimp marinara, lobster with clams, lamb chops, steak siciliano, rice pudding, chocolate mousse cakes, cheesecakes, coffee, and tea.
21. Brother’s Pizzeria Restaurant in Staten Island, NYC
Brother’s Pizzeria is a casual dining spot on Richmond Avenue. It’s a great place to taste Italian cheese pies with delicious sauces and various toppings. They have comfy seating and a relaxing atmosphere where you can enjoy tasty pizza slices with drinks. Their menu is Cheese pizza, Hawaiian pizza, Sicilian, Margherita, and Buffalo chicken pizza. They also serve rice balls, beef patty with cheese topping, potato croquettes, garlic bread, chicken tenders, fried calamari, buffalo wings, grilled chicken, grilled shrimp, house salad, antipasto, calzones, cheesesteaks, pasta, lasagna, and spaghetti.
Conclusion:
New Yorkers love Italian food whether it’s pizza, pasta, or mac n cheese. However, it is not a densely populated area, but Staten Island is Known for its rich Italian culture and culinary scene. You will find various casual eateries, cafes, and classic luxurious Italian restaurants that offer delicious Italian meals, signature dishes, an elegant atmosphere, and a fine dining experience. It’s a peaceful and calm island to enjoy the fresh ocean breeze, scenic views of NYC islands and its historical landmarks, a great culinary scene, and refreshing vibes.
